Technology in Theory and Practice: "Hack This! Contesting Technological Neutrality at Technology in Theory and Practice”
Guest Writer: Mel Stanfill

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

[On April 2, 2012 the Unit for Criticism held its annual Graduate Student event. This year it was a panel of three graduate students on the topic of Technology in Theory and Practice. Below guest writer Mel Stanfill, one of the panelists, writes the second of two posts on the event.


"Hack This! Contesting Technological Neutrality" 

Written by Mel Stanfill (Institute of Communications Research)

The consensus was clear at the Technology in Theory and Practice graduate student panel: across the various disciplinary homes, theoretical frameworks, and methodological approaches of the participants, technology is not a neutral tool that can magically solve our problems without any input from us.

Mark Keitges (Education Policy, Organization, & Leadership) critiqued the idea that education can be optimized through carefully controlled design. In particular, he used Hans-Georg Gadamer's idea of “being pulled up short” to highlight the role of uncertainty and surprise in education. Because being jolted out of our complacency and worldview is a productive experience, “improving” designs to make the learning process  smooth isn't an improvement at all. Instead of “distributed cognition," in which some of the work of thinking is relocated into the technology, Keitges seeks recognition that the capacity for learning doesn't reside in the technology but in the interaction. He called for an “ill-structured design” that affords such moments of disjuncture.

Safiya Umoja Noble, (Graduate School of Library & Information Science) was similarly interested in disrupting narratives that claim that technology cures what ails society. Noble was concerned with the ways “black girls” appear when these search terms are “Googled,” finding that the results that appear first, far from ushering in a new era under Stewart Brand's slogan “information wants to be free,” operate entirely within the orbit of old stereotypes that reduce African-American women and girls to their sexuality. She was particularly concerned because Google search is typically presented as not only neutral but also a “public good” that improves life by making information available to the masses.



Noble was critical of the ways Google has at times specifically disclaimed responsibility and identified objectionable results as “the algorithm's fault”--even when such results are produced by gaming their system, as in neo-Nazis Googlebombing the word “Jew” or, to add a lighter example, Dan Savage's campaign against Rick Santorum.

My own presentation for the panel, which derives from my work in communications research may seem to diverge from these perspectives by arguing for the usefulness of data analysis software to critical research. However, my work nevertheless resonates with that of my co-panelists: like them, I believe that the software is only as good as what the user puts into it. With insightful interpretation on the part of the researcher, software can turn micro-level analysis into macro-level insight by showing patterns in how social categories are understood—in my case, sports and science fiction fans, but the principle is portable—across disparate cultural locations.

Within these three papers, despite their great variance with respect to topic and discipline, then, a number of commonalities emerged. Keitges and Noble are both interested in the ways that technology's design renders certain uses more or less possible in ways that then affect the world (as, in other work, is Stanfill). Noble and I want to expose and contest the ways in which certain ideas get produced as the reality of the categories in our research and how this helps perpetuate unequal power relationships. And, while Noble and I disagreed about the usefulness of data analysis software, ultimately our points are similar: analytical software is helpful when (and only when) researchers need to keep track of large bodies of things.

This combination of commonality—in seeing technology as an important site of interrogation—and divergence—in how the presenters approached it—formed the heart of the faculty response, provided by Ted Underwood, who identified the panelists as participating in a form of critique that he compared to “hacktivism”: Keitges was hacking design, Noble was hacking search, and I was hacking research.

In place of the disciplinary silo effect, or even inderdisciplinary silos such as the contemporary movement for Digital Humanities Underwood called on his listeners to hack scholarly communication itself. This starts, of course, with bringing such a panel and audience together in the first place.

However, Underwood also called for hacking scholarship by recognizing that the technologies that organize us as scholars are no more neutral and independent of human action than Google or educational interfaces or data analysis software. The academic publishing system, for example, is a technology, and recent activism to contest scientific publisher Elsevier's pricing practices, resistance on the part of academics to the Research Works Act, and broader initiatives for open-access publishing (and for recognition of open-access publications as legitimate) are also modes of hacking scholarly communication.

And indeed, Kritik itself is part of the hacking all of the panel's participants ultimately find necessary—in providing a public forum, this blog works to contest the common sense about what technology is for, how to use it, and what will be seen as a legitimate way to get knowledge about the world.

If, as the panelists argued, technology is only as good as what we do with it, let's do something with it. Hack this post. Remix it. Transform it.

71 comments

Make A Comment

71 comments:

Ted Underwood said...

Thanks so much, Mel, for this sharp summary of a great conversation.

Just to extend my thoughts about disciplinarity a little: I actually don't object to "disciplinary siloes" as such. If a discipline supports the kind of inquiry you want to pursue, then I'm all for it. In cases where a discipline isn't working for you, I would say: just create a different community. That's how we got "the digital humanities," and I think moving outside existing disciplines was absolutely a useful move in that case.

I might also characterize DH as more "extradisciplinary" than interdisciplinary. To me, scholarship is interdisciplinary when people still feel institutionally based in English departments or what have you, but do intellectual work that crosses disciplinary boundaries. DH feels a little different in the sense that it's really building its own institutions and infrastructure, both on the web and in the more traditional form of journals and conferences, etc. But I don't think it's likely to become a "department" either. And it includes about as many academic professionals as it does faculty. In short, it's something kind of anomalous.

handbagschn said...

I hate the rain, mostly Louis Vuitton Handbags because I usually so unprepared it makes everything more miserable. But if you avoid getting wet and chilled, and oncedreary downpours could even be fun. It all Bottega Veneta Handbags attitudend accessories! If youe got the right gear to look forward to wearing, the rest will fall into Bottega Veneta Handbags . Here are my Five Essentials to keep me sane on days when there isn any sun in sight. Now go jump in some puddles! Marc by Marc Jacobs PythonPrint Automatic UmbrellaDon Gucci handbags when it comes to your umbrella. There nothing more frustrating than a broken one when you need it like the last time I was in NY and went through street corner Hermes Handbags and still ended up wet!, so get an umbrella with a good mechanism. And toy with wild designs. This one reveals my love of a certain reptile.On NetaPorter for . Burberry MidCalf Buckle Rain BootsThanks to smart designers catching on to the fact that we all Miu Miu Handbags care to wear clunky galoshes, it now proven rain boots dont have to look like rain boots. With a wraparound strap and low rise, these are cool and functional.At Saks Fifth Avenue for . MICHAEL Michael Kors Trench RaincoatIts already looking dismal enough out there, so do your part to cheer up the atmosphere spring for a Mulberry Handbags colored raincoat! Color works wonders for mood ?and so does a good cut. This one is tailored just right with Prada Handbags slightly oversized lapel and a hood for protection.At Neiman Marcus for . Eric Javits Patent Rain HatAcid rain is murder on the hair! Even if you dont live in acidy LA, keeping Alexander Wang Handbags head dry is key to staying warm ?and keeping your blowout in tact. Flirt with the showers and wear one with a wide brim and a whole lot of shine.At Saks Fifth Avenue for . Yves Saint Laurent Patent HoboRain is when a patentleather bag is most useful. With Cartier Handbags umbrella in tow, you already have a lot on your hands, so why risk another precious thing you have to protect? I have been tucking my bag into my coat, but I have enough to Celine Handbags with so I switching to highgloss until the weather clears. Be carefree. Let it get wet and dry it off with a towel, easypeasy!At Neiman Marcus for
I hate to even mention the word ackpack?so early in August and I will avoid that dreaded phrase, ack to for the Chloe Handbags of our tots, but, lets face it, time is flying. And besides, I can let these adorable Beatrix New York backpacks slide by without notice! Designed for ages

Disable people said...

Great post. Its very interesting and enjoyable. Its must be helpful for us. Thanks for your nice post.
disable people
famous disabled people

telepathy show said...

Wow, Excellent post. This article is really very interesting and effective. I think its must be helpful for us. Thanks for sharing your informative.
corporate entertainer

John Smith said...

This article is efficient. Thank you for sharing it with us. I am visiting this blog on a daily basis and I am finding so much helpful article each time. Keep working on this and thank you once again. xnxx

Unknown said...

I found myself wonder to read this article. This is pretty impressive and here you have pointed out some superb details. Thanks for sharing this with your readers.
Personalized Gifts for Kids

Unknown said...

Buy Personalized Elmo CD

Unknown said...

cheap ed pillsImprove every aspect of your sex life! Longer staying power, increased performance & faster recovery.

Receap said...

Minecraft Premium HesapMinecrafthesabim.com sizlere çok daha uygun fiyatlı bir şekilde minecraft premium hesap satmak amacıyla kurulmuş bir şirkettir. Şirketimizde çalışan bütün kişiler konular hakkında yeterli bilgiye sahiptir ve Minecraft Premium hesabınızla ilgili bir sorun olduğu zaman 7/24 ulaşabilmeniz için hazır beklemektedirler.

Rafid said...

hepsibahis Hepsibahis güncel web sitesine buradan direk giriş yap. Youwin adı ile bilinen Türkiye ve Kıbrıs üzerinden canlı bahis ve casino slot oyun hizmeti veren siteye erişim sağlayın. Hepsi bahis firması için yeni giriş adresi sadece burada.

Aslam said...


bahis siteleri Avrupa da yasal olarak faaliyet gösteren bir çok güvenilir bahis sitesi için güncel giriş adresleri Bahis5XL sitemizde. Bahis5XL.com ile bir çok yabancı bahis şirketi hakkında tanıtım yazılarını inceleyerek, size uygun en iyi iddaa sitesini seçebilirsiniz. Canlı bahis siteleri için en çok bedava deneme bonusu veren Kıbrıs ve Malta lisanslı Türkçe bahis sitelerini Bahis5XL ile inceleyin. Türkiye nin en güncel 2020 bahis siteleri listesi burada.

Receap said...

1xbet Türkiye 1xbet Türkiye, online bahis şirketi hakkında giriş ve inceleme bilgileri. Onebahis firması için 2020 güncel yeni giriş adresi, ödemeler ve üyelik işlemleri için detaylı bilgiler, 1xbahis sayfamızda yer almakta.

Aslam said...

meal kits Making cooking a little easier. It's hard, it takes time and who's got the time after a long day of work, looking after kids and being on your feet all day ? I bet you don't and neither do I.. making cheap and tasty modern day meal kits the new normal among all the changes going on in our world today.

Hero said...


less than one dollar web hosting Domain hosting can be hit and miss when it comes to finding it cheap. Don’t get me wrong there are cheap web hosting options, but how about “super cheap and affordable” web hosting. Less than a dollar is “truly” affordable web hosting and this is a chance to get access to web hosting that is consistent and reliable when it comes to affordable web hosting.

Receap said...

BUY SPOTIFY PLAYS REAL PLAYS TO BOOST YOUR MUSIC.
We will promote your tracks and give you very good promotion Buy spotify plays

Rafid said...

Business News OIBNews is India's leading network by NDTV and CNN contributors. It has been serving the best out of the mess from World and India.

Haider said...

best investment strategist GET UNIQUE INVESTMENT IDEAS FROM AN EXPERIENCED FUND MANAGER TARGETING 5X - 10X+ RETURNS.

Rafid said...


Faster way to fat loss

Receap said...

baanpolball บ้านผลบอล (baanpolball) อัพเดทตลอด 24 ชั่วโมง ราคาบอลวันนี้ วิเคราะห์บอลแม่น ฟรีๆ ทุกคู่ 100% ทีเด็ดบอลวันนี้ 4 คู่ ราคาบอลไหล แบบเรียลไทม์

Haider said...


bydleNÍ

Haider said...

finance

Rafid said...

judi online

Receap said...

green xanax Xanax pills can be bought from leading online pharmacies. Due to their immediate release nature, once you have taken a Xanax tablet you will begin to feel its soothing effects in under half an hour.

Aslam said...

BydleNÍ

James said...

Online Reputation Repair Reputation Repair Service removes criminal history information and deletes criminal records. Creates positive content that replaces negative search results.

kawser said...

500 1 million best downloads 1millionbestdownloads.com offers a variety of downloads in several different industries. Our downloads range from general, to software, services and to even making money. These downloads come in many formats from ebooks, to signups, traffic generation, hosting, marketing, finance, arts and entertainment, cooking, investing, employment, games,

Mira said...

AKciE

AR Rahman said...

FINanCE

Aslam said...

FBDown

AR Rahman said...

รับซื้อรถยนต์

Rafid said...

British shorthair for sale We have been branded as the best cattery for breeding healthy kittens and puppies ready for a home.

Haider said...

dankwoods,

dank woods,

Aslam said...

canim sohbet Android Dear ChatCanım chat is growing day by day with the android chat service it has given to you and serves you, dear chat lovers, free of charge. You can connect and chat online at any time of the day with your smart devices on our chat site. Anonymous chat is a free chat site that allows you to chat randomly and does not charge any fee or money from our valued chat users.

James said...

Casinos Now Compare the best legit online casinos that pay real money including the best crypto casinos, best mobile casinos and the best online casinos in 2021

Hero said...

SEO Packages India We offer the best SEO packages across the world. We are the best SEO Company and we dare you to beat us

jeewangarg said...

Hire Jeewangarg.com the PPC Expert in Delhi
, India & maximize your sales at the lowest cost. Jeewangarg is a certified Google AdWords Specialist in Delhi. Therefore, if you are in search of potential customers from Google, there is no substitute for our excellence PPC service.

Servo said...

BHI Makeup Academy is the leading best Makeup Academy in Mumbai. It provides long term, short term along with the advanced courses in makeup, hair care and beauty therapy. Grab your seat in top-rated pro courses, world class makeup hair training and become a pro makeup artist along with the skilled and proficient knowledge.

nexusups said...

Avail one of the widest ranges of Online UPS with cent percent efficiency with internal and external batteries. Buy NexusUPS as they provide customized designed solutions across the industry verticals to require varied and specific requirements. They provide the best Online UPS Price along with the on-time delivery to their prestigious clients.

Sigma Test said...

Testing Lab in Delhi- STRC providing testing facilities to the industries worldwide. We assure trusted quality control by testing your products with highly accurate measuring.

bhimakeupacademy said...

BHI Makeup Academy is the leading best Makeup Academy in Mumbai. It provides long term, short term along with the advanced courses in makeup, hair care and beauty therapy. Grab your seat in top-rated pro courses, world class makeup hair training and become a pro makeup artist along with the skilled and proficient knowledge.

Chanson Water said...

Chanson water company Taiwan - the world leaders in manufacturing highest quality alkaline water machine since 1979.

s said...


servo stabilizer
is a prominent manufacturer, providing a wide range of Servo Stabilizer Manufacturers in India and an array starting from 5 KVA to 5000 KVA for residential, industrial and medical use. Stabilizers installed after qualifying a 35 points Checklist while undergoing Intensive Quality & Reliability inspection to withstand 170/300V besides 270/470V, manufactured in the state-of-the-art manufacturing plant with the latest cutting-edge innovative technology adopted after rigorous in-house R&D done since inception

phautecouture said...

Pakistani Designers are synonyms to luxury fashion house defined by eternal sophistication, elegance and glamour. The designers have an innate and typical sense of style and a passion for creating contemporary designs, and this philosophy has been the defining force behind the fashion label, that is familiar for its innovation, gorgeous expertise and exceptional attention to detail. Buy the latest outfits designed by the Pakistani Designers at Panache Haute Couture at remarkable price and discount.

Haider said...

epoxy lantai blitar Kami adalah jasa epoxy lantai blitar terbaik saat ini. Mengapa harus memilih kami? Karena kami berpengalaman lebih dari 20 tahun sebagai aplikator epoxy lantai terbaik. Hubungi dengan konsultasi gratis kepada spesialis pengecatan epoxy lantai kami di ☎️ 0811-8677-782

Rafid said...

Liberty caps mushrooms online

Quality Spare Center said...

Sandblasting is also known as abrasive blasting. Primarily, sandblasting is a procedure of by forcibly propelling a stream of sandblasting material against a surface. The sandblasting operation is done under high pressure to smoothen a rough surface, shape to eradicate its contaminants. There are various variants of sandblasting procedures like bead blasting, shot blasting, and Soda Blasting, however, if you are in search of the best and powerful Sandblasting Machinery contact Quality Spare Center for the best of machinery and sandblast materials.

seo company India said...

Very good addition. This article has excellent points and I’m glad that I’ve read this. Get Affordable SEO services at a cheap price!!!

Hero said...

virtual reality in education

AR Rahman said...

Property management

Unknown said...


Digital marketing( Widest Digital Media ) is the component of marketing that utilizes internet and online based digital technologies such as desktop computers, mobile phones and other digital media and platforms to promote products and services.
Ping Back :- Best Digital Marketing Company In delhi

Haider said...

buy saxenda online we focus on developing clients and improvement in healthcare. Our leading solutions include a predictive and action-oriented business intelligence platform, fully integrated retail, specialty and outpatient pharmacy solutions, and much more. Our products and services are designed to help drive operational results for our customers while improving outcomes for patients.

best seo in india said...

Best SEO Company in Delhi
Carpet Cleaning Cannington
Best Astrologer Mumbai
fridge repair delhi
ro repair delhi
treadmill repair in delhi
House Cleaning in Patna

James said...

dank vapes official account

Tile Cleaning Services in Perth said...

best seo company in delhi
best astrologer mumbai
fridge repair delhi
ro repair delhi
treadmill repair in delhi
house cleaning in patna

Aslam said...

motherhood CO.MOM is a fun new online magazine and social network community created by moms for moms. Read interesting articles, get advice from our agony aunt, aunt\y anne, learn how to earn an income online with our guru debbie or you can even seek medical advice from our resident physician dr samantha and relax while checking out the latest horoscopes from our trained mystic. Theres even a thriving forum community where moms of the world can get together and enjoy good conversation along with lots of other fun ways to kill some time with a cuppa when taking a break from being super mom at co.mom.

seo company India said...

Very good addition. This article has excellent points and I’m glad that I’ve read this. Get Affordable SEO services at a cheap price!!!

Rafid said...

World News

Haider said...

polyuria As a worldwide leader in industrial coatings and spray-on truck bed liners, ArmorThane offers a full line of top-quality polyurethane and polyurea coatings and high-tech spraying equipment and supplies. Our professionally applied pure and hybrid polyurethane and polyurea formulas are extremely durable, flexible and safe.

Haider said...

polyurea As a worldwide leader in industrial coatings and spray-on truck bed liners, ArmorThane offers a full line of top-quality polyurethane and polyurea coatings and high-tech spraying equipment and supplies. Our professionally applied pure and hybrid polyurethane and polyurea formulas are extremely durable, flexible and safe.

Vipul Singh said...

I liked your article, kindly keep updating us.
Sinusitis Surgery in Meerut
Top English Medium School in Meerut
digital marketing institute in meerut
Jaina Jewellers Meerut
SEO Services Provider
family law solicitors in london
Transfer of Property in London

Najaf Qureshi said...

I just visit your website and I found it very informative. Please share more content just like that. I want to read more content so please upload more articles. Thanks in advanced.

Packaging Host

Die Cut Stickers

Static Cling

Cheap Latest Products

Property Saga

Lahore Smart City

Nova City Islamabad

Park View City Islamabad

Al Noor Orchard Lahore

Spider Business Center said...

If you are looking for virtual office in dubai-? Spider Business Center provide flexible virtual offices for rent in Dubai.

SUPPREM said...



Totally loved your article. Looking forward to see more more from you. Meanwhile feel free to surf through my website while i give your blog a read.
welcome to Newsome Maltese Puppies
where to buy Maltese Puppies
Maltese puppies
Maltese Puppies For Sale

Spider Business Center said...

Want to Do New Company Setup in Dubai? Contact UAE #1 Company Setup Consultants for business setup services and company formation in Dubai.

Trionfo IT Services said...

Thank you for your valuable and useful information through the blog. I am appreciating with the way you shared the relevant, precious, and perfect information. Furthermore, I would like some sound knowledge of Digital Marketing Company in Delhi . Here Trionfo IT Services Pvt. Ltd is a Delhi-NCR, INDIA based IT firm delivering high quality, cost effective, reliable result-oriented web and e-commerce solutions which also include training for all the services on time for a global clientele Services Reach our Website you will get complete information related Your Query…

Connect Business Center said...

Connect is the Business Centers Dubai that offers an ideal choice for fledging companies to easily establish with instant, flexible and ready to use professional office spaces and wide range of services to set up quickly.

James Williams said...

Very nice blog, Thanks for sharing great article.
You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
Keep posting like this informative articles.
Thank you.

From: Field Engineer

For more information about: it security operations engineer

bigpond webmial setup (08) 6102 0008 said...


Nice blog site dear I'm about to suggest this to all my listing contacts.
Bigpond webmail support

ravsitsol said...

Thank you, for providing these tips. Personally,
I believe the best strategy is to repurpose the old content into a new useful one.

Jessica Lucas said...

The new report by Expert Market Research titled, ‘Global Chocolate Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the global Chocolate Market, assessing the market based on its segments like categories, product types, growth, qualities, processed types, applications, and regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market upcoming years. The chocolate market is being driven by the growing demand for chocolate in the food and beverage industry, as a popular flavouring ingredient. For instance, chocolate is used in producing cookies and cakes, and can also be found in beverages, Additionally, the wide variety of chocolates available in the market are also attracting further consumer investments, which is expected to positively impact the market growth. The major players in the market are Nestlé S.A., Ferrero Group, Mars, Incorporated, Mondelez International, Hershey Co., Barry Callebaut AG, and Kerry Group plc, many others are lead of this industry. Expert Market Research provides market intelligence across a range of industry verticals which include Pharmaceuticals, Health, Food and Beverage, Chemical and Materials, Energy and Mining. For more information about us, Kindly visit our website also.

Rafid said...

touch up paint bottles

top