Jennifer Doyle: "Sex, Paranoia & the Workplace" - Response by Tim Dean

Monday, April 3, 2017

posted under by Unknown
[On March 30, the Unit for Criticism & Interpretive Theory hosted the lecture "Sex, Paranoia & the Workplace" The speaker was Jennifer Doyle, Professor of English at UC-Riverside. Below is a response to the lecture from Tim Dean, Professor of English.]

Response to Jennifer Doyle's "Sex, Paranoia & the Workplace"
by Tim Dean, Professor of English

Jennifer Doyle and I met for the very first time today; but I have admired her work for over a decade, and all the more so after reading her recent book, Campus Sex, Campus Security (published by Semiotext(e) in 2015).  One of the things I admire most is her capacity to keep the critical lens focused on sex, especially at a time when the field of Queer Studies has retreated from the difficulties of thinking sex in favor of other objects of study.  From her first book, titled Sex Objects: Art and the Dialectics of Desire (2006), Professor Doyle has focused on how libidinal energies and impasses shape the cultural and social fields.  This focus strikes me as deeply psychoanalytic, even when Doyle steers clear of particular psychoanalytic methods and vocabularies.  In my remarks today, I want to situate her reading of Freud’s “Case of Paranoia” in relation to her work as a whole, before opening the floor to discussion.  I would like to articulate a number of observations and questions, but I will try to be brief.

In both her reading of Freud’s case and her recent book, Doyle is interested in the desires, anxieties, and disavowals that structure the workplace—including our workplaces at public universities.  In her reading of Freud, she has an explanation for why the workplace has become intolerable for the woman in question.  And in her book Campus Sex, Campus Security, she has an explanation for why our working conditions at public universities have increasingly become intolerable.  But they are not the same explanation, even though both turn on “sex.”

In her reading of Freud’s case, Doyle raises the possibility of a non-pathological paranoia—what she calls “a healthy kind of paranoia.”[1]  When conditions are structured to prevent a certain possibility for a particular class of persons in the workplace (here, women), then something like a paranoid response appears reasonable.  Calling it “paranoia” is a way of de-legitimizing the response, a way of denying that what the woman has perceived is real.  It’s all in her head.  Doyle is right to claim that, no, it’s not all in her head, it’s structured into the conditions of her workplace by the gendered division of labor.  The woman in Freud’s case, quite apart from the “revenge porn” scenario she conjures avant la letter, is perceiving something that the professional men involved staunchly disavow, namely, the workplace as a sexual space.

But what exactly does it mean to describe the workplace as a sexual space?  It means something different in Doyle’s reading of Freud than it does in her reading of public university campuses in the 21st century United States.  In her reading of Freud, Doyle draws on a particular Italian Marxist-feminist account of labor—associated with Silvia Federici and Leopoldina Fortunati—to argue that the woman in Freud’s case is caught in the contradictions that structure the capitalist division of labor between production (in the workplace) and reproduction (outside the workplace).  In this schema, sex is “not only administered as that which ‘happens’ outside the sphere of work; it is positioned as ‘the opposite’ of work.”[2]  There is thus no conceptual space for accommodating sex in the workplace and, indeed, no possibility of acknowledging sex as itself a form of work.  This is one way of explaining why our society cannot really think through the category of sex work—and why male sex work in particular seems to short-circuit rational thought.  To grasp how sex and work are not each other’s opposites likewise obliterates the distinction between pleasure and labor that organizes Max Weber’s Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1930).

At the end of her reading of Freud, Doyle refers to “the collective disavowal of the fact that ‘work’ is always already sexed.”[3]  Here, I believe the term “sexed” means gendered—i.e., the workplace is structured by a gendered division of labor that uniquely disadvantages women.  I have no quarrel with that claim, but I worry about how the term “sex” has slid from meaning something libidinal—sex as in fucking—to meaning sexual difference, sex as a term European feminists use where we would be more likely to use the term gender.  The fact, as Doyle puts it, that “‘work’ is always already sexed” is not the same as saying that the workplace is a sexual space.

Another way of articulating my concern would be to say that the Marxist feminist critique of the gendered division of labor, valuable though it is, keeps in place a distinctly heterosexual paradigm for understanding sex.  That paradigm makes it harder to see how, for example, same-sex sexual harassment functions in the workplace or on campus.  When gender difference organizes your concept of sexuality, certain things become invisible, or much harder to perceive.  This is a problem with the intellectual tradition Doyle is drawing upon in her reading of Freud; but it’s a problem that does not appear in her book Campus Sex, Campus Security, where she uses the term “sex” differently.

What Doyle describes as a collective disavowal of the libidinal dimension of the workplace takes an historically specific, neoliberal form on contemporary college campuses.  In my view, that disavowal helps to explain how queer theory, once it became institutionalized in the university, stopped paying attention to sex.  In the mid-1980s, Gayle Rubin announced—in an article (“Thinking Sex”) that inaugurated the field—that “The time has come to think about sex.”  But by the end of the millennium, queer theorists had simply decided they would prefer not to.  Jennifer Doyle represents a notable exception to that institutional retrenchment, and I am profoundly grateful for the searching brilliance of her latest book. 

One of the things Campus Sex, Campus Security makes evident is how “sex” has become what renders the campus and its administrators insecure.  The most acceptable campus discourse about sex is how to stop it from happening.  In the latest incarnation of a Foucaultian nightmare, sex has become something that must be, above all, administered.[4]  Outside of biology labs, there is virtually no space on campus for actually thinking sex.  There are plenty of campus spaces for thinking about how to get sex.  And every campus has multiple sites for engaging intellectually with questions of gender (even though those sites tend to be under-resourced and under attack).  But if you’re searching for a place on campus to theorize human sexuality apart from a biological model, you are basically out of luck.   

Sex is not supposed to contaminate the campus as a workplace.  Now, when I went to college in the 1980s, it was precisely in order to have sex (and perhaps secondarily to reflect on what that meant).  All my undergraduate feminist friends talked incessantly about which professors they wanted to shag; as students we speculated endlessly, and in minute detail, about what various faculty members would be like in bed.  I’m not sure how much has changed since then (you tell me); but what has changed is the growth of a large and complex bureaucracy to administer sexual complaints.  At universities such as the ones Doyle describes in her book, the campus bureaucracy has become increasingly militarized, not to mention paranoid about securing boundaries in a way that deserves to be diagnosed as pathological.  (We are not talking here about “a healthy kind of paranoia.”)

When my college friends and I generated a discourse whose sole object was our professors’ sex lives, we did so as a result of the phenomenon that Freud named transference.  “He whom I suppose to know, I love.”  Transference is a psychoanalytic term for describing the libidinal energies that pervade relationships structured hierarchically.  Transference is the engine that drives psychoanalysis in a clinical setting and it permeates hierarchical institutions such as schools.  It’s a way of talking about the libidinal component of our relationship to authority.  I would argue that sex haunts the workplace in large part because transference goes unrecognized and unacknowledged.  Freud said that the essence of psychoanalysis lay in handling the transference.  One might say that the essence of teaching lies similarly in handling the transference that permeates pedagogical relationships.  When a teacher or a student fail to recognize that what’s happening between them is transferential, that’s when they are most likely to end up having sex.  And by now we have a pretty good idea of how that story ends.

Let me redescribe what I’m trying to get at here.  In the Marxist-feminist critique of the division of labor that Doyle invokes, there is a division between production and reproduction that creates an impasse for women in the workplace and fails to acknowledge certain kind of labor as labor.  Partly in response to this impasse, Italian Marxist philosophers such as Maurizio Lazzarato and Antonio Negri have developed the concept of immaterial labor to describe “labor that produces an immaterial good, such as a service, a cultural product, knowledge or communication.”[5]  In my own research on sex work, I’ve been using the idea of immaterial labor to think through forms of affective labor, aesthetic labor, and glamour labor.  What psychoanalysis adds to this account of immaterial labor is the crucial idea of unconscious labor—the work that our minds do, in the service of pleasure, unbeknownst to us.  (Freud uses the term arbeit, the basic German word for work, to describe this mental labor)  We might say that the unconscious is the ideal laborer of capitalism because our minds continue working even when we’re asleep.  What they produce is a called a dream—an immaterial product if ever there were one.

Transference is a way of talking about the unconscious component of all human relationships that are structured hierarchically.  It acknowledges that there is another kind of work going on, work that is intentional but eclipsed by consciousness.  The workplace is a sexual space because every human being who occupies that space is accompanied by a ghost, namely, their unconscious.

[1] Jennifer Doyle, “Rethinking a Case of Paranoia as a Workplace Complaint,” Studies in Gender and Sexuality, vol.18, no.1 (2017), 10.
[2]  Doyle, “Rethinking,” 11.
[3]  Doyle, “Rethinking,” 12.
[4]  Here Doyle’s account recalls political anthropologist David Graber’s brilliant critique of contemporary bureaucracy in The Utopia of Rules: On Technology, Stupidity, and the Secret Joys of Bureaucracy (2015).
[5]  Michael Hardt and Antonio Negri, Empire (Harvard University Press, 2000), 290.


Make A Comment


Unknown said...

شركة تنظيف خزانات بحائل
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالجبيل

Unknown said...

Very interesting post!
شركة تركيب طارد حمام بالرياض

check said...

Because the erectile dysfunction pump motor becomes complete, it creates an erection. A rubber rig will end up being clicked within the lower penis to help keep the bloodstream within the penis and maintain the hard-on. Search for a brief video clip below detailing exactly how a vacuum pumps motor works check ….

Tony Stark said...

You are writing some interesting and Best content I also bookmark this URL...You guys are writing some Amazing tips. This article really helped me a lot. Thanks for sharing this. Totally Awesome Post Please Keep Posting Regularly... you are totally awesome...

Clipping Path said...

Amazing post with lots of informative and useful and amazing content. Well written and done!! Thanks for sharing keep posting.

AAB College said...

Thank you for sharing

Kate Kross said...

Having an assignment due tomorrow and understand you can’t do it yourself? But you’re afraid of delegating your paper to some scam services as well? Why not check right now?

Tina Lorens said...

If you're looking for a date but not sure whether the dating site is a safe place, check our review.

San Francisco said...

Thanks for sharing this information.

If you looking for tour packages, then I want to introduce about to Get the best exclusive World Tour Packages at Smart Travel Fair. Enjoy International Tour Packages from USA Tour Packages,California ,San Franciscoand Los Angeles at affordable prices. Call us @ +1 (888) 362-2444.

Jolly Angeles said...

good job ,your information is helpful and rocking.. New Orleans Vacation PackagesFull fill your USA travel need with us and ask for travel packages on Toll Free no:- +1(888)362-2444

David Millar said...

It’s a good resource for learning. I see the post again and again. Photo Retouching Services

professional photo editing said...

So excellent your shared written blog . A lot of thanks for this published . Clipping Path | Product Photo Editing

Buy Nuvigil online said...

No matter what age we belong to or what we do. if we are students trying to score well in exams or a professional trying hard that pending promotion or just an adult who is fighting hard to fight dementia, the idea of taking a pull to boost our brain functioning seems little appealing. Thus today it is no surprise that the use of the smart drug also known as nootropics is on a rise. In the past, the term nootropic was used to refer to chemicals that met certain criteria. However, today the term nootropic is used for any kind of natural or synthetic compound that affects the brain functioning of a person positively. The smart drug that is advancing over time is Nuvigil smart drug. People wishing to get this smart drug can buy Nuvigil online.
Buy Nuvigil online

alice marvel said...

Excellent and very informative blog click here
Quickbooks Proadvisor Support Phone Number and for more detail dial on 844-908-0801

Buy Provigil 200mg said...

Provigil is a very effective smart drug that helps us to stay awake and active. This smart drug is a brand of Modafinil that also can work as a mood enhancer and brain booster. Provigil 200 mg got the approval of the FDA in 1998. You can get this smart drug easily in the market. You also can buy Provigil online to get this smart drug at an affordable price.
Buy Provigil 200mg

atharveducation said...

Being a member of the Association of Indian Universities (AIU), the programs are recognized by WES. Students may verify the same from the WES platform for Canadian Immigration. NMIMS Distance Education program serves its students with highly innovative and revolutionary technology and offers every digital solution to enable faster and most tactful learning process to its students.
nmims distance fee payment
nmims distance university
nmims college distance education
nmims distance result
nmims online distance learning

DY Patil Distance Learning program is aimed towards a slick and rapid improvement in the process of education while maintaining the contemporary standards of the educational industry in the genre of Hospitality and Management. Being renowned as a sophisticated university, DY Patil has several tie-ups with some of the best international industries.
dr dy patil vidyapeeth pune distance mba
ajeenkya dy patil university distance education
dy patil distance education mumbai
dy patil university distance education
dy patil institute of distance learning admission 2020

The School of Distance Education and Learning has executed the same schooling pattern from its mother university and continues to spread its remarkable influence across Rajasthan. The students and alumni members are provided with innovative self-learning study materials. JNU Distance Learning also offers consistent and well-organized counselling programs to its JNU Distance Learning students by renowned and experienced counsellors right at their doorsteps.
jaipur national university distance education bca question paper

jaipur national university distance education contact details

jaipur national university distance education login

jaipur national university distance education ba

\jaipur national university distance education results june 2020

atharveducation said...

Bachelor of Pharmacy (B.Pharm) is an undergraduate degree course in the field of Pharmacy education. The students those are interested in the medical field (except to become a doctor) can choose this course after the completion of class 12th (PCM/B). After the completion of this degree, the students can practice as a Pharmacist. The duration of this course is 4 Total years.
soma 350mg dosage
bachelor of pharmacy
best bachelor of pharmacy college
bachelor of pharmacy admission
bpharm colleges
bpharm Admission
best college for bpharm
bpharm mumbai
bachelor of pharmacy admission mumbai
bachelor of pharmacy mumba
bpharm admissioon mumbai

globalonlinepills said...

The issue of erectile dysfunction can be more complicated at times than we usually think. No men would want to suffer from erectile dysfunction. It not just affects them physically but also leaves a deep impact on the minds of the person.
Viagra 100 mg
viagra 100 mg price
Generic Viagra 100 mg
Viagra 100 mg tablet price
Erectile dysfunction is a condition where a man is not able to get an erection. Even if they are able to get an erection, it does not last for too long. Suffering from erectile dysfunction can affect the person both physically and mentally. Therefore a person needs to take medical help to make the condition better. Also suffering from erectile dysfunction can affect the relation of the person with their partners.
Viagra 200 mg
viagra 200 mg price
Generic Viagra 200 mg
Viagra 200 mg tablet price
Erectile dysfunction or impotence is a health issue that is suffered by men. In this problem, the man becomes unable to get the perfect erection. Irregular blood flow in the body is the cause of this problem. This problem may happen because of various reasons.
Viagra 150 mg
viagra 150 mg price
Generic Viagra 150 mg
Viagra 150 mg tablet price

onlinepillsmart said...

Some pain pill cannot cure your pain. Yet it can help you to get effective and temporary relief from body pain. This painkiller can work best when it is taken with rest and proper treatment.
Soma 500mg
tablet Soma 500mg
500mg Soma

Unknown said...

Provigil 200 mg is a smart drug that is effective in keeping away the mental fatigue. Mental fatigue can occur due to physical as well as emotional symptoms. This puts an impact on the person’s behavior, that others may notice even before the person feels.
provigil 200 mg buy online
tablet Provigil 200mg
200mg Provigil

pierciiiiingss said...

Hello, I want to have one of these piercing models, but I am unsure. Can you look at it?

Christina Piercing

Rook Piercing

Lip Piercing

Tragus Piercing

Dermal Piercing

Tragus Piercing & Piercing

Cut Out Way said...

Wow, pretty cool tips. I really appreciate your post. I definitely visit this blog again
Background Removal Service
Clipping path Service

Sumon Ahamed said...

Wonderful Post. I appreciate your blog. Well done for shared. Really useful resource! Thanks for sharing. Clipping Path | Background Removal Services | Car Photo Editing | Neck joint Services | Drop Shadow Services